(Note: this is is not an official Department of State website; the views and information presented are my own and do not represent the Fulbright Program or the U.S. Department of State.)

Saturday, August 13, 2011

Window Shopping: Commercialism and Museums

While working through my copy of A Companion to Museum Studies, in Sharon Macdonald's chapter entitled "Collecting Practices,"¹ I came across the following:
"Creating a collection required the ability to make careful selections from the profusion of objects that had become more widely available during the eighteenth century and especially into the nineteenth. Not only were there still enormous quantities of exotica and novel things to cope with, there were also new, mass-produced goods. New things became more easily available to a wider range of people than ever before, especially in the department stores that sprung up alongside museums in the expanding cities. Museums and department stores sometimes borrowed design features from one another; and both put objects on display through the tantalizing technology of the vitrine or glass case, in which things could be seen and admired but not touched, the possessive appetite thus being whetted but not immediately satisfied. The shop, though, made possession a real possibility; and the new production of "collectibles"--items designed specifically to be collected--tapped into this possibility and market. The perceived danger, however, was that people would be so dazzled by the new acquisitive possibilities that they would not know when to stop or how to select responsibly. This was articulated especially clearly in the disease of 'kleptomania,' which first came to be identified at the time. and which was a particular affliction of the middle-class ladies in department stores (Abelson 1989)." (86)
Reading this excerpt was like finding a long-lost puzzle piece in the couch cushions. After all, isn't visiting museums alarmingly similar to window shopping? At least for me, as a poor, recent college-grad, ogling Chagall in MoMA is not all that different from ogling Chanel on 5th Avenue. Part of the reason I enjoy Chagall more than Chanel, although for many reasons, boils down to two reasons that this passage indirectly raises. For starters, originality. Although I do recognize and appreciate fashion design as art (and perhaps one that people find more readily accessible, as evidenced by the overwhelming popularity of the Alexander McQueen exhibit at the Met), the fact that the Chanel purse I'm coveting on 5th is simultaneously being displayed in thousands of venues across the globe, for me, detracts from its glamor. Which brings me to my second point: there's no real temptation for acquisition in a museum. As we've established, I can afford neither the purse nor the painting, so why not "possess" the latter in an intellectual, emotional manner instead?

However, things get especially tricky when that line between museum and mall is blurred. In his article "Museums and Globalization,"² Saloni Mathur addresses in part the commercialization of both museums and their exhibitions. He lists two of the Guggenhiem's exhibitions as examples: The Art of the Motorcycle (1998) and Giorgio Armani (2000/2001). What makes things morally sticky are their sponsors; Motorcycle being sponsored in part by BMW, one of the featured manufactuers, and although Armani was officially sponsored by In Style magazine, it did follow an individual gift to the museum by Armani himself--for the reported sum of 15 million. Mathur writes:
"Increasingly, it seemed that museums were not only being sponsored by corporations, but that their practices were becoming inter-woven with a corporate model, effectively blurring the boundaries between the world of museums, the world of Hollywood, the world of fashion design, while also creating a convergence of interests between these powerful economic sectors." (700)
It's no surprise, then, that China is jumping on the proverbial band-wagon. Currently on display at the National Museum of China is the exhibition Louis Vuitton Voyages, which marks a few milestones: the 20-year anniversary of LV in China, the museum's second major exhibition since it's reopening in March 2011, and perhaps most importantly, the museum's first partnership with a major consumer brand.³


Photo Credit: Katie Morton (Also, thanks for letting me crash on your couch in Beijing!)


And yet, in the Jing Daily's article "Zhou Chunya: Let Luxury-Art Partnerships Increase Art Appreciation in China," contemporary artist Zhou espouses this relationship:


Over the past two years, major fashion brands have — one after another — cooperated with artists on a range of activities. Chanel created its “Mobile Art” exhibition, Hermes is planning its H-BOX show, LV has hung works by Zhou Tiehai in its stores, and Prada has projected films by Yang Fudong on the walls [of its boutiques].
Some people say that these arts activities are just a matter of luxury brands engaging in high-end marketing in the name of art. So then, as independent artists, should we refuse to serve as a high-end marketing tool for luxury brands? Personally, I feel the answer is, “not necessarily.” Art needs independent creation, but it doesn’t necessarily need “independent display.” Why can’t we use their popularity to promote art? Especially because they can attract so much media and public attention.
          [....]


When luxury brands spare no effort to emphasize that “our products are also works of art,” getting help from their art initiatives, they’re actually also doing another thing — they’re exposing the general public to true works of art, letting people know what art is. Even famous arts venues like the Shanghai Art Museum that host large-scale events have trouble attracting more than 5,000 visitors a day. But how many people pass by a downtown luxury boutique and stop to take a look in the window every day?
China’s luxury consumers are increasing, and within five years China may be the world’s top luxury market. If the world’s leading luxury brands can bring art to these consumers, art will naturally reach a greater audience. And as high-end consumption gradually becomes a way of life for people, we could expect art to become a part of these people’s aesthetic consciousness as well. 

Yes, this general trend has received a lot of criticism and yes, I personally think it feels a little dirty. But as MacDonald pointed out and is reiterated by Mathur, the nineteenth century witnessed the rise of not only the museum, but also the department store, the world fair, and the arcade--commercialism has, and always will be, at its roots. Although museums are oftentimes glamorized and idealized as a secularized "Cultural Cathedral," we cannot ignore its realities. A museum is no shrine; it's a building with walls, pipes, and endowments. Curators are not priests, but rather persons with goals tempered by budgets and concepts tempered by reality. With the current economic climate, this is also reflected by the shift of museum directors with Art History PhDs to directors with MBAs (one such example being the appointment of Jeffrey Deitch to the Los Angeles Museum of Contemporary Art in 2010).

Let's stop kidding ourselves: everything does boil down to money. Too bad in this field, I'll never be seeing any of it. In the meantime, I'll console myself with the Chagalls at the MoMA and the ancient bronzes at the National Museum.



Citations:
¹ MacDonald, Sharon "Collecting Practices" in Sharon MacDonald, ed., A Companion to Museum Studies. Malden: Blackwell Publishing, 2006.
² Mathur, Saloni. "Museums and Globalization."Anthropological Quarterly 78.3 (2005): pp. 697-708.
³ Event Watch: Louis Vuitton "Voyages" Exhibition at National Museum of China: http://www.jingdaily.com/en/luxury/event-watch-louis-vuitton-voyages-exhibition-at-national-museum-of-china-beijing-may-29-august-30/

Saturday, August 6, 2011

Chinese Semiotics

A lesson in Chinese Semiotics, brought to you by the National Center for the Performing Arts, Beijing:


From left to right, top to bottom:
  1. No wolves
  2. No kites
  3. No platform roller blades (although regular ones are subject to consideration)
  4. No amputees playing with spherical objects
  5. No littering
  6. No cars
  7. No sitting on ping-pong tables (while cross-legged)
  8. No bicycles
  9. No pointing at small flowers
  10. No trumpets
  11. No bicycles with bike racks (in case you thought you thought you were exempt from #8)
  12. No exploding Christmas trees
  13. No camp fires
  14. No Chinese characters*
*This is actually the character shòu, which means "to sell"

A special thanks to Annie for not only taking the photo with her Iphone, but also for her witty contribution to the interpretation of these icons. If you have your own readings, feel free to post them below!

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Addendum:

How could I have possibly forgotten this earlier gem, spotted in a Xi'an restaurant:

(Insert your own caption here)


Friday, July 29, 2011

The Fashion Question

Let me start by saying that I could write a book—nay, volumes—on Chinese fashion. That being said, if I had to summarize in a sentence, I’d have to say that it’s much like the country itself: multi-various, self-contradictory, and in transition. Not to mention, just generally confused.

Believe me when I say that people watching takes on a whole new dimension here—it could be a competitive sport. First off, it goes without saying that the subject pool is significantly larger. I myself have two ways to play: category or ensemble-based. For the former, pick a category, be it footwear, dresses, or Chinglish graphic T-shirts, and start comparing. If targeting footwear (my personal favorite), arbitrarily assign points for various attributes, be they bows, lace, or sequins. Otherwise, you can examine the relationship between heel-height and degree of tottering, or even tally the number of people wearing platform shoes with unbuckled straps (how they walk in such a state is entirely beyond me). Another fun case study is to survey the relationship between multi-hitters—in this case, women wobbling in sky-reaching bejeweled, lacy heels with bows—and purse-holding, crutch boyfriends (note that when I say “crutch,” I mean it quite literally; remove the man’s supportive arm and she’ll surely topple over like a poorly-constructed Jenga set).

But let’s take a moment to go back to the ensembles. As an art major and a former Banana Republic sales associate, the entire outfit is, of course, quite important. Hypothesizing how Item A and Item B were selected is almost always a fun brainteaser. My current existing theories include 1) Dressing in the dark; 2) A highly experimental Arp-inspired clothing collage—i.e., throwing clothing and accessories on the floor, and allowing chance and gravity to determine the result. The alternative—that the pink, frilly flower-print dress was in fact intended to be paired with the green, sparkly flower-print flats—is honestly a bit too much to bear.

Perhaps I’m being a tad bit harsh. Let me clarify by saying that not everyone is bizarrely dressed, especially not with the rise of the upper-echelon and 名牌--name brands. Fashion is certainly changing here. After all, the true test for the popularity of any given trend is whether they’ve started making cheap knockoffs in China.

Which brings me to my earlier point, which is the fact that Chinese fashion is in a constant state of flux. Having spent time here summer of 2008, I prepared for my return trip with longer skirts and modest necklines. I remember being flummoxed by the girls in the height of summer wearing jeans and t-shirts. Just the thought of any additional or unnecessary fabric makes me schvitz.

While there’s still quite a bit of that modesty, you wouldn’t believe how things have changed since then. The hemlines have jumped to an unseemly degree, and are coupled with high heels to boot! Of course, the effect is a bit different on a twiggy, anorexic Chinese girl than it would be on her better-nourished, more buxom counterpart. All the same, I wouldn’t have guessed.

In sum, the one rule for fashion—like for the rest of China—is that there are no rules. The fashion question has no answer. For a brief introduction, you can check out this blog: Accidental Chinese Hipsters.

Enjoy!

Monday, July 25, 2011

Sedaris vs. China

Thank you, Annie, for sending along this article on Chinese food by David Sedaris. Check it out for a good laugh.

I won't deny the truth in what he says, HOWEVER I promise that it's not always this bad. Also, I think Sedaris makes some excellent points about American's culinary biases and overzealous dietary restrictions.

Also, sometimes intestines or hacked-up meat is actually quite tasty.

Sunday, July 24, 2011

Soundtrack

Perhaps this is ridiculous, but do you ever wish that your life had a soundtrack? Or maybe even that you could hire someone to follow you around with a boom box, playing music to complement your moods: an I'm-feeling-contemplative song, a Go-and-get-it anthem, or even a simple, classy, yet upbeat Stroll-about-town ditty.

Perhaps it's vanity, or maybe just too much television that lets us pretend our lives have any true cinematic value. No, the world isn't feeling blue just because I am, nor should it mirror those sentiments acoustically.

However, just now as I sat in a coffee shop, reading a book and facing the window, it started to rain. Well, that's no shocker--it's rainy season and the sky has been rumbling for the past twenty minutes. And yet, the big, fat drops that steadily pitter-pattered on the pavement coincided with the instrumental piece playing on the speakers; the clinking piano keys underscored the temporal drama that unfolded outdoors.

And just like that, the moment passed--the track changed, the rain stopped. But how lovely, for just a moment, to have witnessed the coalescence of life and art.

Is it vanity, or just the nature of good music? After all, isn't music powerful for the way that it can tap into our emotional psyche, seamlessly cross languages and cultures, and speak to us on a deeply personal level, where language oftentimes fails?

May we all find a little music in our lives. Perhaps even a theme song.

Yeah, that'd be pretty neat.

Thursday, July 14, 2011

Perspective(s)

In the past six weeks, I’ve ventured to Western China, relocated to Hangzhou, visited the States and come back again. Well, almost. I’m writing from the skies, 5881 miles from Shanghai.

I suppose you could say things are a bit unsettled. I have 14 remaining weeks, and am trying to figure out what to do with them. What is feasible? Will things actually come together, like I've been hoping? I feel suspended between panic and apathy. How can I make the most my remaining time here?

Aside from just my research, people have been asking me for months about my post-Fulbright plans. The answer is that I don’t know. My visa expires October 30th, and I haven’t the slightest clue what city, what country, or even what continent I’ll be on by Halloween. As a rather type-A individual, this is all very troubling.

At right about this point, I start hyperventilating and begin to anxiously scour various museum employment databases. However, times like these require some much-needed perspective. At the very least, I try to stop and appreciate just how lucky I am to have had such unique experiences, to have seen such incredible things, and to have met such wonderful people.

Before arriving back in Hangzhou and starting a new chapter there, I’d like to take a moment to pause and appreciate my time spent in Xi’an. Even with all of my travels, it still remains my favorite Chinese city.

Below, I’m going to include a series of photographs taken during my stay there. Perhaps it will encourage you to visit the city for yourself. If you do, I’ve got a booklet of recommendations waiting.



I. Art and Architecture
South City Gate (2/3/11)

Bell Tower (2/3/11)

Bell Tower by Night (3/27/11)

Drum Tower by Night (3/27/11)

Small Goose Pagoda (2/12/11)

Vendor at Small Goose Pagoda (2/12/11)

Small Goose Pagoda (2/12/11)
\
Big Goose Pagoda (3/26/11)

Close-up of Stele at Xi'an Stele Museum (1/17/11)

II. Terracotta Warriors

Warriors site: Pit 1 (3/13/11)





Rear-view of an archer-figure; note the textured sole of his boot

Warrior-figure at Shaanxi History Museum (6/27/11)


III. Muslim Quarter
View from Drum Tower of food stall by beginning of Muslim Quarter (1/17/11)

Vendors in Muslim Quarter (3/26/11)

Contemplating wooden frogs (3/26/11)

串儿 (skewered meet) Vendor (3/26/11)


Dried fruit (3/26/11)

Muslim chef preparing paomo (3/26/11)

IV. Friends

With Cai Wenjin (Kathy) at the Big Goose Pagoda (3/26/11)

Monica's Wedding (4/30/11)

With Cherry, co-worker and friend, at Monica's wedding reception (4/30/11)

Xi'an Fulbrighters at their finest:
Good food and good times with Annie and Alina (5/13/11)

Post-biking the city wall with friends Danny and Rachel (6/26/11)


With my contact Cai Laoshi--Shaanxi History Museum employee/artist--in his office
(6/27/11)

Reunion with high school Chinese teacher Cheng-Mei
at Shaanxi History Museum (6/16/11)

Wednesday, June 29, 2011

皮影戏 píyǐngxì (Shadow Puppetry)

I'm blessed to have some extremely smart, creative, and passionate friends. Because of their different fields and interests, interacting with them helps me view and understand my surroundings in new ways. For example, my sister can parse words like nobody’s business. My friend who does theater lighting design taught me how to really appreciate light. Another friend, who is an aspiring film director, views her world through a camera lens; whereas I tend to think of things in terms of static images, spending time with her helps me consider other factors like movement and sound.

Most recently, I've had the opportunity to become friends with a puppeteer named Annie. A fellow Fulbrighter, she's spending her grant exploring Chinese shadow puppetry, or "following the puppets" as she likes to put it. More than just researching the art form and its artisans, she's actually cutting them; she calls it "researching with her hands."

Before meeting Annie, I had no idea that China even had shadow puppets, or that they date back so far as the Han Dynasty (206 BCE-220 CE; click here for some background info). However, by spending these past few months chatting with her, reading her incredible blog, and visiting where she works in Xi'an, she's helped me dig into into this vibrant, complex ancient Chinese art form.

As a would-be art historian, spending time with artists is always an eye-opening experience. Sure, I can analyze the effects of line, color, shading, and composition, yet I shamefully cannot produce anything of my own. Observing the artistic process first hand—not only the creative, but also the technical side—is always very humbling.

Watching the masters cut, deftly maneuvering their knives through treated sheets of leather, you'd think it's like slicing butter. Annie can assure you first-hand that it’s not. 

Annie cutting leather
Puppet-cutter at work
(maybe it's not immediately obvious, but this is an extremely thick
hide. She had to stand up in order to cut it, yet it still appeared to be effortless)

Again, you’ll have to excuse my fixation on line, but oh, it's magnificent! The precision and detail of the curves, swirls, and jaggedy-bits are truly exquisite. Once you’ve seen a masterfully hand-cut puppet, it’s hard to appreciate anything less--certainly nothing of the machine variety.

Unpainted puppet-head

Painted female head in front of book with puppet prototypes

As if their artistry wasn't enough, never-mind the fact that they move! The puppeteers control them with such finesse, all the while singing in affected dialect. In traditional performances, they’re accompanied by an ensemble of erhu, pipa, and percussion. It’s loud, strident, and janky in the best of all possible ways.

Screen with leather-cut backdrop and puppet to the left
Puppeteer/accompaniment from behind the screen

Before leaving Xi'an, I decided to pick up a few puppets for myself. I walked into a touristy shop along the Muslim Quarter, glanced at the wall, and asked "do you have any hand-cut puppets?" "Wow, you have a good eye," he told me. "Yeah" I responded, "my friend is an expert." 

Thanks, Annie, for bringing puppets into my life.

Friends Annie and Alina playing with a new-style shadow puppet
(It was around this time that they experimented with the moon walk)

Painting studio

An example of furniture/setting accouterments

Small exhibition of puppets by the lead cutting master

Equestrian puppet

Detail of Equestrian puppet

Will you look at her hair?