(Note: this is is not an official Department of State website; the views and information presented are my own and do not represent the Fulbright Program or the U.S. Department of State.)
Showing posts with label Nerding-out. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Nerding-out. Show all posts

Sunday, October 2, 2011

Museums in Motion: Sichuan’s “Museum-on-Wheels”


In the past couple of decades, there has been a democratizing trend in museums. Rather than the "museum-as-the-curator's-playground" phenomenon, since the 1990’s there has been a steady rise in museum education. Whereas museums' early focus was on scholarly research and art conservation, funds are progressively being redirected towards outreach and public programming.

The Sichuan Museum, however, has taken this a step further with their Liudong Bowuguan (流动博物馆), or "Mobile Museum." Rather than just bringing the public to the museum, they are also bringing the museum directly to the public.

The Mobile Museum is the only one of its kind in China. Whereas some museums have similar activities as part of their education programming, Sichuan is unique for having its own eight-person department. Officially initiated February of 2010, this program began with the generous donation of four trucks to the museum. In this way, the staff can literally pack-up exhibitions and bring them to citizens across the province.

Since its inception, the Mobile Museum has traveled to forty places across Sichuan. They target a wide-range of audiences, traveling to distant, mountainous regions, minority villages, and more local areas such as schools, mines, and orphanages. They have targeted areas affected by the 2008 earthquake, and gone directly into schools to teach. When visiting poor minority villages, they have even gifted them with technological supplies and equipment such as projectors.

This program has at least one exhibition per month. These shows are based on the museum’s permanent collection, and have covered topics such as Sichuan bronzes, Han dynasty earthenware bricks, Han dynasty jades, and the Long March.

When I asked how they physically transport and display their exhibitions, staff member Zhu Kaituo gestured to the black metal stands that were stacked behind me. Through a series of photos, I was shown how those stands are used to hang wall paneling with images and text. They are also used to hang scrolls—in one case, facsimiles of paintings by 20th century legacy Zhang Daqian. Although they seem to work primarily with text and images, they also transport artifacts, reproductions, and multi-media materials such as touch-screens and projectors. The museum also brings along its staff to give presentations, artists to do live-demonstrations, and in some cases, even art-appraisers to evaluate the locals' antiques.

Exhibit wall text
A traveling show on Han Dynasty earthenware bricks
Cases containing earthenware bricks
Staff member teaching visitors about bricks

Many Western museums are creating impressive, multi-media websites to make their collections more accessible through extensive image databases and educational resources. However, all of these efforts are based on the assumption that the public not only has access to a computer and the internet, but also has the education-level to use it. Since this is not the case for Sichuan Museum, they've found a more direct and personal way to resolve their gaps in viewership.

For those of you who are curious, here's a video from a Chinese news report about the Mobile Museum. The content is pretty much all covered above, but you can watch it for the visuals.

Kudos to Sichuan Museum for paving the way. Let’s hope that other Chinese museums will follow their lead.

*I claim no credit for any of the above images; they were all taken from baidu's image search engine.

Monday, September 5, 2011

Ancient China meets modern design

It's no news to you that China is a rapidly developing country. As someone living here, it's truly impossible to keep up with. Orange cranes and scaffolding dot the skyline, traffic is continually clotted by construction for new subway lines, and the sound of drills and jackhammers become merely white noise; its the percussion to the honking, clanking symphony that is Modern China.

Yet amongst all of this construction, amongst the repetitive, cheaply constructed blue-and-white-bath-tile buildings, there are subtle intimations of China's ancient culture. Yes, there are new-old buildings and alleys in any given tourist city, readily identifying their "must-see" and "historically rich" status, but I'm not talking about those. What I'm thinking of specifically is how China incorporates its ancient motifs into its modern aesthetic.

The most common example that I've seen is the adaptation of ancient bronzes. Banks, shopping malls, parks, or even roundabouts will occasionally feature a 2000x replica of ritual vessels such as ding (鼎) or gui (簋). 

Replica of a Gui, located in a Beijing roundabout 

More than just that, it's also architecture. Two famous examples include the China pavilion at the Shanghai World Expo and the Shanghai Museum of Art, which are both modeled after ding vessels.


Fang ding at Nelson-Atkins Museum of Art

 
Left: Fang Ding at public part in Luoyang with inflatable model of the China Expo Pavilion in the background
          Right: China Pavilion, Shanghai (October 2010)
Shanghai Museum of Art

Yet perhaps my favorite example is the trash cans that line the city walls in Xi'an, which are modeled to look like zhong (钟), or ancient Chinese bells:

 
Left: Shang Dynasty bronze bells at Shaanxi History Museum
Right: Bell-shaped trash can at Xi'an City Walls

Another common place to catch a glimpse of Ancient China is its many bridges. Examples include motifs from ancient jades, bronzes, and even coins.

Left: Image of Taotie motif on bronze from wikipedia entry 
Right: "Taotie" bridge in Hangzhou

 
Left: Example of Shaman motif on jade from Neolithic Liangzhu Culture (source)
Right: "Liangzhu Jade" bridge in Hangzhou suburbs, located near Liangzhu Culture Museum 


 
Left: Bronze mask from Shang Dynasty Sanxingdui Archaeological site
Right: "Sanxingdui" bronze mask bridge located near Sanxingdui archaeological site, Chengdu suburbs

Bridge with ancient coins in Xi'an

Despite the race towards development and progress, China does seem to have an awareness and respect for its ancient culture. Although I'm unsure of the motives, it does seem to be a unique approach to public art, or even arts education. Here's hoping that it has some sort of enriching impact beyond just the art/history nerds out there.

Saturday, August 13, 2011

Window Shopping: Commercialism and Museums

While working through my copy of A Companion to Museum Studies, in Sharon Macdonald's chapter entitled "Collecting Practices,"¹ I came across the following:
"Creating a collection required the ability to make careful selections from the profusion of objects that had become more widely available during the eighteenth century and especially into the nineteenth. Not only were there still enormous quantities of exotica and novel things to cope with, there were also new, mass-produced goods. New things became more easily available to a wider range of people than ever before, especially in the department stores that sprung up alongside museums in the expanding cities. Museums and department stores sometimes borrowed design features from one another; and both put objects on display through the tantalizing technology of the vitrine or glass case, in which things could be seen and admired but not touched, the possessive appetite thus being whetted but not immediately satisfied. The shop, though, made possession a real possibility; and the new production of "collectibles"--items designed specifically to be collected--tapped into this possibility and market. The perceived danger, however, was that people would be so dazzled by the new acquisitive possibilities that they would not know when to stop or how to select responsibly. This was articulated especially clearly in the disease of 'kleptomania,' which first came to be identified at the time. and which was a particular affliction of the middle-class ladies in department stores (Abelson 1989)." (86)
Reading this excerpt was like finding a long-lost puzzle piece in the couch cushions. After all, isn't visiting museums alarmingly similar to window shopping? At least for me, as a poor, recent college-grad, ogling Chagall in MoMA is not all that different from ogling Chanel on 5th Avenue. Part of the reason I enjoy Chagall more than Chanel, although for many reasons, boils down to two reasons that this passage indirectly raises. For starters, originality. Although I do recognize and appreciate fashion design as art (and perhaps one that people find more readily accessible, as evidenced by the overwhelming popularity of the Alexander McQueen exhibit at the Met), the fact that the Chanel purse I'm coveting on 5th is simultaneously being displayed in thousands of venues across the globe, for me, detracts from its glamor. Which brings me to my second point: there's no real temptation for acquisition in a museum. As we've established, I can afford neither the purse nor the painting, so why not "possess" the latter in an intellectual, emotional manner instead?

However, things get especially tricky when that line between museum and mall is blurred. In his article "Museums and Globalization,"² Saloni Mathur addresses in part the commercialization of both museums and their exhibitions. He lists two of the Guggenhiem's exhibitions as examples: The Art of the Motorcycle (1998) and Giorgio Armani (2000/2001). What makes things morally sticky are their sponsors; Motorcycle being sponsored in part by BMW, one of the featured manufactuers, and although Armani was officially sponsored by In Style magazine, it did follow an individual gift to the museum by Armani himself--for the reported sum of 15 million. Mathur writes:
"Increasingly, it seemed that museums were not only being sponsored by corporations, but that their practices were becoming inter-woven with a corporate model, effectively blurring the boundaries between the world of museums, the world of Hollywood, the world of fashion design, while also creating a convergence of interests between these powerful economic sectors." (700)
It's no surprise, then, that China is jumping on the proverbial band-wagon. Currently on display at the National Museum of China is the exhibition Louis Vuitton Voyages, which marks a few milestones: the 20-year anniversary of LV in China, the museum's second major exhibition since it's reopening in March 2011, and perhaps most importantly, the museum's first partnership with a major consumer brand.³


Photo Credit: Katie Morton (Also, thanks for letting me crash on your couch in Beijing!)


And yet, in the Jing Daily's article "Zhou Chunya: Let Luxury-Art Partnerships Increase Art Appreciation in China," contemporary artist Zhou espouses this relationship:


Over the past two years, major fashion brands have — one after another — cooperated with artists on a range of activities. Chanel created its “Mobile Art” exhibition, Hermes is planning its H-BOX show, LV has hung works by Zhou Tiehai in its stores, and Prada has projected films by Yang Fudong on the walls [of its boutiques].
Some people say that these arts activities are just a matter of luxury brands engaging in high-end marketing in the name of art. So then, as independent artists, should we refuse to serve as a high-end marketing tool for luxury brands? Personally, I feel the answer is, “not necessarily.” Art needs independent creation, but it doesn’t necessarily need “independent display.” Why can’t we use their popularity to promote art? Especially because they can attract so much media and public attention.
          [....]


When luxury brands spare no effort to emphasize that “our products are also works of art,” getting help from their art initiatives, they’re actually also doing another thing — they’re exposing the general public to true works of art, letting people know what art is. Even famous arts venues like the Shanghai Art Museum that host large-scale events have trouble attracting more than 5,000 visitors a day. But how many people pass by a downtown luxury boutique and stop to take a look in the window every day?
China’s luxury consumers are increasing, and within five years China may be the world’s top luxury market. If the world’s leading luxury brands can bring art to these consumers, art will naturally reach a greater audience. And as high-end consumption gradually becomes a way of life for people, we could expect art to become a part of these people’s aesthetic consciousness as well. 

Yes, this general trend has received a lot of criticism and yes, I personally think it feels a little dirty. But as MacDonald pointed out and is reiterated by Mathur, the nineteenth century witnessed the rise of not only the museum, but also the department store, the world fair, and the arcade--commercialism has, and always will be, at its roots. Although museums are oftentimes glamorized and idealized as a secularized "Cultural Cathedral," we cannot ignore its realities. A museum is no shrine; it's a building with walls, pipes, and endowments. Curators are not priests, but rather persons with goals tempered by budgets and concepts tempered by reality. With the current economic climate, this is also reflected by the shift of museum directors with Art History PhDs to directors with MBAs (one such example being the appointment of Jeffrey Deitch to the Los Angeles Museum of Contemporary Art in 2010).

Let's stop kidding ourselves: everything does boil down to money. Too bad in this field, I'll never be seeing any of it. In the meantime, I'll console myself with the Chagalls at the MoMA and the ancient bronzes at the National Museum.



Citations:
¹ MacDonald, Sharon "Collecting Practices" in Sharon MacDonald, ed., A Companion to Museum Studies. Malden: Blackwell Publishing, 2006.
² Mathur, Saloni. "Museums and Globalization."Anthropological Quarterly 78.3 (2005): pp. 697-708.
³ Event Watch: Louis Vuitton "Voyages" Exhibition at National Museum of China: http://www.jingdaily.com/en/luxury/event-watch-louis-vuitton-voyages-exhibition-at-national-museum-of-china-beijing-may-29-august-30/

Tuesday, June 14, 2011

Buddhist Art Pilgrimage II: The Mogao Grottoes

This past week, I had the unique opportunity not only to visit the Mogao Caves, but also to view those currently being photographed by the Dunhuang Research Institute. Wearing a Dunhuang Staff badge (oh, if only it were mine!), my friend Sizhuang and I followed our host around, popping into caves and meeting various staff members.

An oasis on the edge of the Gobi Desert, Dunhuang was an important stopping point along the Silk Road. It became both a major commercial and Buddhist center, and epitomizes the cultural exchange between ancient China and many other countries. Whereas the Longmen Grottoes strictly feature Buddhist relief sculpture, the Mogao Caves contain some of China’s foremost mural painting. There are a total of 492 caves with roughly 45,000 sq. meters of painting. They were executed over a span of 1,000 years; the earliest dates to 366 BC in the Northern Wei Dynasty, and the latest was completed during the Yuan (1279-1368). Dunhuang was largely abandoned with the decline of the Silk Road after the Tang Dynasty (618-907), and the caves were not rediscovered until the early 20th century.

Walking past all of the gated entrances to the caves is like a treasure hunt: you can only imagine what marvels lie beyond each metal door. Upon entering, the initial impression is primarily color. As your eyes adjust from the blinding desert sun to the darkened cave, the lines and designs begin to emerge and piece together. Equipped with a small flashlight, I wound my way across each room, slowly unraveling the composition and getting lost in its dense iconography.

Although each cave is remarkable in its own respect, I was perhaps most impressed by Cave 254 from the Northern Wei Dynasty. Although it is usually closed to the public, we were able to visit it while the research team was working. The head photographer directed his six-person team as they rigged their Canon EOS-1Ds Make III camera to some makeshift sliding scaffolding, and gradually photographed the length of a given wall. The camera was directly linked to a computer, and the technician directed where to move it while manually focusing each image. The amount of detail they were able to capture, including the cracks and texture of the paint, was truly astonishing.

As I stood before a baiyifo (白衣佛), or white-clothed Buddha along the back wall, I was transfixed by his exaggerated, abstracted drapery. Each of its many folds was executed in confident, sweeping lines. Viewing it was truly an active, meditative process--in order to understand it, you must gradually, visually unravel each individual stroke.

It was at this point that I discovered three things:

Number 1: I'm a disegno
To explain, the Renaissance divided into two schools of thought: the colorati (color) and disegni (drawing). The Venetian school, such as Titian and Tintoretto, stressed light and color over line, whereas those from Florence and Milan, such as Botticelli and Leonardo Da Vinci, believed that line and drawing were not only more fundamental to painting, but also of the highest intellectual value.

Since taking a seminar on master prints my senior year of college, I started to truly appreciate the use of line. In this class, my professor taught a most invaluable skill: how to look. I don’t just mean to “look,” but to really look—to actively and intently scrutinize, to take one’s time, and to approach from different perspectives. Of course, as an art major this is an obvious and crucial skill that is applicable to any of the visual arts, but it wasn’t until that class that I began to truly understand. Over a year later, when I stood mesmerized by this one painting, I realized that I'd unconsciously sided-up with the Florentines. Sorry, Rubens, it's nothing personal.

Number 2: "The Noodle Theory"
When we took a lunch break during our third day there, I kept thinking back to the Buddha's sheer drapery that I had seen in Cave 159. As I slurped my delicious hand-pulled noodles, I had an epiphany: the drapery looked just like them. The looping, intertwining noodles appeared strikingly like the intricate, dizzying Tang Dynasty drapery on the miscellaneous Buddhas and flying asparas. So now, I have a potential dissertation topic: "Oodles of Noodles: The interdependent relationship between the development of noodles and painted drapery in the Mogao Caves."
(Just kidding. But still, it could be fun.)

Number 3: The creative impulse
As I stood before each painting, examining its carefully executed brushwork, I wanted nothing more than to sketch. If only my hand could transfer these lines onto the page! If only I could imitate those curves that swirl before my eyes, and stay with me even now. It’s no wonder that modern Chinese artist Zhang Daqian was so moved by these frescoes—who wouldn’t feel the need to absorb and express their beauty? I felt such longing—all I could do was stand there and ache for something that I never even realized I was missing. 

Over the course of our four day long stay, we met a lot of people and learned some of their stories. "People come here with the intention of staying a little while," explained one of our effervescent, photographer hosts. "Then they think 'oh, there's so much, I can just stay a bit longer.' And then they stay for ten, twenty, thirty years--maybe even a lifetime. Dunhuang sucks people in like that. I've been here ten years already. Many of my classmates from the Film Academy are off making big movies, but you know what, I don't think that's for me. I've found happiness here, and I think that's ultimately what I want in life. I think it's enough."

I was truly, deeply touched. These caves have been inspiring people from different cultures and countries for over a thousand years. To find people that have truly found love, joy, and meaning in their work is inspiring. May we all be so lucky.

Although there's no photography allowed in the caves (and thank goodness, otherwise tourists' inconsiderate flashes would only accelerate the degeneration process), I'll include a few from outside the site and of our camel-ride (yes, camel ride!) across the Mingsha sand dunes. 

View of Stupa and Sanwei Mountain Range by the Mogao Caves

View of Northern Mogao Caves

Construction workers at the caves

Mingsha Sand Dunes

Camel ride across the dunes






Saturday, April 9, 2011

A Sutra in Stone: The Longmen Grottoes (龙门石窟)

As previously mentioned, the motivation behind my entire trip to Henan was visiting the Longmen Grottoes. Let me start by saying that it was entirely worth it. Even if the trip hadn't been as wonderful and productive as it was, the grottoes would have compensated for everything--they managed to even exceed my high expectations. While I'm going to let my photos do most of the talking, they really can't capture the sensation of being on-site.

For starters, if you want to read up on the grottoes, you can begin with the UNESCO Cultural Heritage Website. Upon request, if you want to practice your Chinese I can also send you an essay I wrote last semester on one of the caves (woo!). Excuse me while I nerd-out, but here are a few key points (from the aforementioned source):
  • The caves divide into four periods
    • Period 1 (493-534): Emperor Xiaowen of the Northern Wei Dynasty moved his capital to Luoyang in 493, and commissioned the earliest caves
    • Period 2 (524-626): Some small caves were carved
    • Period 3 (626): Majority of the Tang Dynasty caves were carved, which are considered to be the site's artistic highpoint
    • Period 4 (755-1124): Late Tang-Northern Song period, decline in cave carving
  • The caves are limestone
  • Is considered to be the apex of Chinese cave statuary
  • Total of 2,345 niches or grottoes, which house over 100,000 Buddhist statues, roughly 2,500 stelae and inscriptions, and over 60 Buddhist pagodas
  • There are 3 sources of damage to the caves: 
    • A number of statues were decapitated or extracted by early 20th century collectors (ending up in museums such as the Met in NYC, the Nelson Atkins in Kansas City, and the Tokyo National Museum)
    • Other statues were mutilated during anti-Buddhist purges or the Cultural Revolution (1966-76)
    • Natural weather-related damange
The largest and most famous cave at Longmen is Fengxiansi (奉先寺), which was commissioned in the Tang Dynasty by Tang Gaozong (唐高宗) and Wu Zetian (武则天), the latter being the sole female empress in Chinese history. Amazingly enough, the cave was completed in only four years. It was built not only to promote Buddhism, but also to protect the area from Tibetan attacks.

Although every cave is magnificent and each of its figures are masterfully carved, this cave truly is something else. Gazing up at its five-story Lushina (Losana) Buddha was an ethereal experience. The refined carving, the attentiveness to the human form, the range of facial expressions, the variation in line, and the exquisite detail all express the love, passion, and faith of their carvers and commissioners.

In sum: if you make it to China, it's worth a trip to Luoyang. If you pay for my accommodations, I'll even accompany you there. Yes, you're welcome.

Until then, here are some photos for your viewing pleasure:

View of some of the West-Bank Caves

One of Three Binyang Caves (宾阳三洞)
Another of the Three Binyang Caves (宾阳三洞)

Lotus Flower Cave (莲花洞)

Bodhisattva Figure

Caves along the West Bank

Fengxiansi (奉先寺)
Lushina Buddha at Fengxiansi
(Allegedly a portrait of Empress Wuzetian, the commissioner)

Fengxiansi
Warrior Guardian (力士) at Fengxiansi

(Hehe. Sorry, couldn't resist)
(Most likely) Prince Ananda at Fengxiansi
Travel-buddy Emi on the East Bank with Yi River in the background 

Vassar Reunion at Longmen

View across the Yi River of West Bank Caves
(You can see the scale of Fengxiansi, the large cave in the center)

Sunday, April 3, 2011

Museum Etiquette

In an earlier post, I mentioned how museums were a potential outlet for the cultivation of proper social behavior. However, my experience today at Henan Museum made me realize just how far China still has to go. 

The things I saw today were so appalling that just
thinking about it gets me worked up. Apologies in advance for the rant, but I'm going to outline the most fundamental rules to being a civilized museum visitor. If I catch any of you doing any of these things, I'm going to drag you out of the gallery by your hair, and then proceed to beat you with a heavy exhibition catalogue. Consider yourself forewarned.
In the States, they remind you not to use flash
In China, they remind you not to spit

MUSEUM RULES:
1) When the sign says "Don't Touch," that also includes leaning against an invaluable 1,918 year-old relic 
Yuan An stele, Eastern Han dynasty, 92 CE
Plaque reads: "Yuan An Stele is the most complete seal script
tablet discovered in modern times (1961). The inscription features
a broad style, which is a transitional form from small seal to official [script]."
I snapped this photo, and then told the guy "Hey, um, the sign says not to touch"
(Also, you can barely see it here, but there is a railing 2-feet in front of the tablet
Clearly, it's very effective)

2) I don't care if it's an original or a replica, stone animals (regardless of how cute they might be) are NOT props to sit your child on for photos. It's disrespectful, not to mention dangerous. 
I didn't get a photo with the toddler on top
(I really, really hope this is a replica)

3) Never eat in the galleries. I don't care how hungry you are--it's messy and just plain rude. Not to mention, how did you manage to get an ice cream cone in here, and what POSSIBLY made you think that would be a good idea?

4) When you wipe your oily hands (that you didn't wash after using the restroom--I would know, because I watched you leave) against every glass case in every single gallery, it makes it difficult to view the artifacts. Not to mention, it's unsanitary. And just plain gross. 
Blurry hand
(That's because she's repeatedly raking her hand up and down against the glass)

5) Do not scream in the galleries. And yes, this is coming from a very vocal person. Museums require "inside voices." No one wants to hear your entire conversation, believe me. Especially when you're yelling about the foreigner in the gallery. And yes, I do understand you.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

It's neither my country nor my culture. But regardless, isn't it just common courtesy? I recognized that it wasn't my place, but I still had a hard time keeping my tongue in check.

All of this aside, I had an incredible visit to the museum today. It's quite likely the best that I've visited thus far in China. I'm still compiling my notes and photos, but a big post on Henan museums is on its way. Get ready.

Monday, March 28, 2011

If you send an art-nerd to China...

... she'll run around the country checking sites off of her "Monument list!"

Perhaps it won't come as a surprise to you that my Chinese "to-do" list is comprised of various Buddhist grottos, museums, imperial complexes, museums, tombs, and... oh yes, museums. For this reason, I'm not everyone's favorite travel buddy. That being said, if you're looking for an art historical whirlwind tour of China, let me know. I might be available.

One of the top places on said monument list is the Longmen Grottos. When one of my Vassar classmates decided to come visit, I was able to convince her to join me on my Wei-Sui-Tang Monumental Buddhist Sculptural Quest. No, I didn't even have to twist her arm. This art-tastic pilgrimage turned into a small tour of Henan Province, which then evolved into a full-fledged research trip. Thanks to my very gracious and accommodating contacts, I've been put in touch with different staff members at Kaifeng, Luoyang, and Henan museums, and will even be attending an exhibition opening? Or so I've been told.

Unsurprisingly, I'm both very excited and nervous. I'm assembling research on each of the museums, and reading up on the cities and their histories. I've charged my camera batteries, picked up a digital recorder for the interviews, and prepared/translated a series of questions.

I'm playing with the big boys now, so wish me luck! Updates and photos to follow--prepare yourself for some nerdy goodness.

Friday, February 18, 2011

Cultural Norms and "Proper Behavior"

One of the biggest and most aggravating cultural difference in China is the definition of proper behavior and self-conduct. For those of us from Western countries, rather shocking behavior includes the following: people spitting/shooting projectile snot onto the street, dogs and children urinating/defecating in public spaces, reckless littering, and the inability to form lines (note: in China, push and shove and you will get there faster). 

It's difficult to enforce niceties in a country this big with a population this large. There's a very real mob mentality in effect-- "everyone else does it too, so who cares," right?

For the record, I'm not condoning littering as "okay" since it's a "cultural norm." However, in order to stay sane you do have to reach a certain level of acceptance, or an understanding that, "no, I can't change this, but I won't participate either." Not to mention, you must also develop an awareness of your surroundings, i.e. do not step in that puddle of liquid, because there's a 95% chance that it is NOT water.

What brings me to this point is something I stumbled upon in my research. I'm reading an article on Nantong Museum, China's first private museum established by Zhang Jian, an early 20th C politician. The following excerpt, referencing early Western museums, particularly caught my attention:

The museum was one of the first institutions to reshape and manipulate what was later to become general norms of public behaviour. The “modern museum idea” was that museums should be places of “civilizing rituals,” and museum visitors, through cultural cultivation, should become self-monitoring, and thus a regulatory force in themselves. This, however, remained an ideal in the West until the completion of a century-long overall improvement in education and parallel developments in architecture and technologies. 58
58. Conn, Museums and American Intellectual Life, 1876–1926, p. 6; Bennett, The Birth of the Museum, pp. 6–7, 48–58.

I had no idea. With current development of both Chinese education and museums, does this mean that there's hope on the horizon for the improvement of these "general norms of public behavior"? From what I've heard from Chinese people, they're already making progress. Internationally recognized events such as the 2008 Beijing Olympics and the 2010 World Expo in Shanghai were both occasions for public education on proper social behavior.

I'm keeping my fingers crossed. I'd rather not have to dodge spit like miniature missiles when I'm out and about.

Sunday, December 12, 2010

"Does Language Shape How You Think"

My classmate Wang Kai showed me this article, and I found it so interested that I wanted to share it with all of you. It was posted in the NY Times a couple of months ago, and is about the impact of language on your thought-process. 

Since studying abroad in college, I have become convinced that in order to TRULY speak a foreign language fluently (or even just fluidly), you have to abandon your mother tongue and think in that language. Anyone who has been immersed in another language will know that this is extremely difficult, but not impossible to do. It is, however, a quite unnatural. My friend Nathan suggested that it is a self-imposed, multiple-personality disorder. I don't fully subscribe to this strong analogy, but I think that there's a hint of truth to it. When I am in China speaking Chinese, I am "Ningqi." In fact, if my Chinese friends call me "Nicole," it feels very strange. "Ningqi" adopts Chinese sounds, Chinese mannerisms, and Chinese expressions. What is truly disorienting is when these elements carry over from one language to another. For instance, I've caught myself using Chinese grammatical structures when speaking English. It is quite sad to regress in one's own mother tongue.

What I want to ask Guy Deutscher (the author) is what the study of foreign languages does to change your "thought process." I feel like there's really something to this. Its one of the reasons I love languages so much, I feel that it really does "open your mind." Its also the reason why regardless of how many books you've read, you cannot be an expert in a foreign culture until you are proficient in the language. You cannot begin to understand their thought process until you've been immersed, and have adopted it. 

Moreover, what does this mean for bi-lingual children? Is this why it generally takes them longer to start speaking? Is their "scope of thought" wider than monolingual children?